1
The Exes
by Leonora Darlington (2026)
★4.13(4)
Like 'Valentine's Slay', this features deadly dating scenarios with a dark, suspenseful twist.
thrillermystery
10 Books Similar to “Valentine’s Slay” by Navessa Allen
Valentine’s Slay
by Navessa Allen (2026)
★3.85(13 ratings)
Louisiana gravedigger Noah Evans’s Valentine’s night shift takes an unexpected turn when his high school crush starts screaming from her freshly dug grave. Whoever tried to bury Emma six feet under is in for a nasty surprise—they should have checked for a pulse because she’s got unfinished business, starting with the hot gravedigger who just saved her life. As they unearth a deadly family conspiracy, Noah and Emma discover that old flames burn even hotter the second time around—especially when someone’s trying to kill them.
Get this book:
Similar Books You'll Love
2
A Serial Killer’s Guide to Marriage
by Asia Mackay (2025)
★3.78(16)
This shares the dark romance and thriller elements of 'Valentine's Slay', exploring a dangerous relationship.
dark romancethriller
3
Pretty Little Wife
by Darby Kane (2020)
★3.70(66)
Similar to 'Valentine's Slay', this offers a twisty, suspenseful tale with unsettling romantic undertones.
thrillersuspense
4
Verity
by Colleen Hoover (2018)
★3.73(1.0K)
Like 'Valentine's Slay', this book delves into a dark and unsettling romance with a thriller element.
thrillerromance
5
Kill Your Darlings
by Peter Swanson (2025)
★2.55(10)
This shares the dark and tense atmosphere of 'Valentine's Slay', focusing on a deadly cat-and-mouse game.
thrillermystery
Want More Personalized Picks?
Tell us what you love and get AI-powered recommendations tailored to your taste.
Get Personalized RecommendationsPowered by MyNextBook — AI-powered book discovery