1
The Dead and the Dark
by Courtney Gould (2021)
★4.12(30)
Like 'My Dearest Darkest', this sapphic horror novel explores dark secrets in a secluded town.
horrorya
10 Books Similar to “My Dearest Darkest” by Kayla Cottingham
My Dearest Darkest
by Kayla Cottingham (2022)
★3.95(20 ratings)
When transfer student Finch Chamberlin and popular senior Selena St. Clair accidentally wake something terrifying and ancient in the depths of their school, they must work together to stop the horror they unleashed before it consumes the town.
Get this book:
Similar Books You'll Love
2
Sawkill Girls
by Claire Legrand
★5.00(1)
This dark YA horror shares 'My Dearest Darkest's' unsettling atmosphere and focus on young women facing supernatural threats.
horrorya
3
All That Consumes Us
by Erica Waters
Similar to 'My Dearest Darkest', this gothic dark academia novel delves into the darkness of human desires.
dark-academiahorror
4
The Society For Soulless Girls
by Laura Steven (2022)
★3.29(21)
This dark YA thriller echoes 'My Dearest Darkest' with its elite boarding school setting and supernatural mysteries.
thrillerya
5
Daughter of the Bone Forest
by Jasmine Skye
Like 'My Dearest Darkest', this sapphic dark fantasy features a dangerous courtship and a looming conflict.
fantasyya
Want More Personalized Picks?
Tell us what you love and get AI-powered recommendations tailored to your taste.
Get Personalized RecommendationsPowered by MyNextBook — AI-powered book discovery